The Swamp logo

Nancy Pelosi Is Second, Not Third, in Line for the Presidency

A Category Error

By Paul LevinsonPublished 5 years ago 1 min read
Like

My wife Tina called my attention to a funnily annoying meme last night: Commentators on MSNBC keep saying that Nancy Pelosi (as Speaker of the House) is "third in line for the Presidency." I just heard Stephanie Ruhle and Malcolm Nance say that.

But, actually, the Speaker of the House is second, not third, in line. The President is not first in line—he's already there (unfortunately) in the White House. The first in line to succeed him is the VP. And the Speaker of House is second in line.

Look at it this way: If you're waiting in line to see a concert, the person who is lucky enough to be first in line is not yet seated or even in the theater. If the line has been moving, everyone who was first in line who entered the theater is no longer on line. (They could be online, reading their email or tweeting, but that's something else.)

Ruhle and Nance and everyone who has been getting this wrong could benefit from Bertrand Russell's theory of logical types. If you're counting all the clothespins in a bag, you don't count the bag, too. I realized a while ago that even people who pick up the trash understand this. You empty the garbage pail, but don't take the pail away with the garbage. The pail itself is not garbage.

Regarding the President, whoever is in that office is not on any line of succession. That's because the person in that Oval Office has already assumed that office. It's even incorrect to say that Nancy Pelosi is third in command. The responsibilities of government don't work that way. In many ways, the Speaker of the House is far more powerful than the Vice President.

But she does stand behind the Vice President in one very significant regard. She's second in line to succeed the President, behind the VP who is first in line.

president
Like

About the Creator

Paul Levinson

Novels The Silk Code & The Plot To Save Socrates; LPs Twice Upon A Rhyme & Welcome Up; nonfiction The Soft Edge & Digital McLuhan, translated into 15 languages. Best-known short story: The Chronology Protection Case; Prof, Fordham Univ.

Reader insights

Be the first to share your insights about this piece.

How does it work?

Add your insights

Comments

There are no comments for this story

Be the first to respond and start the conversation.

Sign in to comment

    Find us on social media

    Miscellaneous links

    • Explore
    • Contact
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms of Use
    • Support

    © 2024 Creatd, Inc. All Rights Reserved.